Thursday, September 24, 2009

Abstract

Remember, there are two parts to the abstract:

1. The summary of the article/criticism
2. Your opinion: You agree or disagree- evidence is needed from the criticism.

Include the source in your writing.

Have fun posting.

48 comments:

  1. are we supposed 2 post the abstract thing here?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, please post abstracts here (who is fairies415)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Emily Gallivan
    AP Literature- Period 1
    Abstracts
    September 27, 2009
    Mr. Di Leo
    David J. Kelly, in an essay for Novels for Students, Gale, 1999.
    The protagonist of Ernest J. Gaines's A Lesson Before Dying is Grant Wiggins, a young black man living in the South during the 1940s. Grant has been assigned the task of teaching a convict how to die like a man before his execution. David J. Kelly, the literature and creative writing instructor at College of Lack County and Oak- ton Community College, has found that Grant Wiggins is a difficult and disagreeable character and addressed this dislike for him in his essay. Mr. Kelly notes that Grant never wholly appreciated the good in his life, and constantly complains of feeling trapped by his aunt and held back by Vivian. Kelly provides the reader with some understanding of Grant's hypocrisy throughout the novel by noting that he always says he loves Vivian, but cannot define love, and is always distracted from his students, then complains that they never learn. Kelly concludes Gaines was clever in creating a complex character such as Grant Wiggins, because he was "neither saintly nor profoundly flawed," and that one learns much more seeing Grant's world through his eyes.
    I believe I agree with David J. Kelly's interpretation of Gaines's use of a character like Grant. I at first found Grant to be an unpleasant narrator, and someone I had difficulty understanding, as his lack of faith in the world annoyed me, making the novel slightly challenging to get through. However as the novel went on, and the changes in Grant made him simpler and less stubborn, I found the storyline to be more moving. Grant provided excellent insight into the world of the 1940s, which shows how Gaines made the right decision in creating a character who was not a saint, who felt trapped by society and was most certainly bitter because of it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. David Skrill
    AP Literature- Period 3
    LBD Abstract
    9/27/09
    Mr. Dileo

    Through her synopsis of the interaction between Grant and other characters in Lessons Before Dying by Ernest Gaines, Jennie Poston analyzes the complex social web between characters in the novel to exemplify how humans affect each other. By identifying the factors which cause the growth of Grant as a character, Poston isolates the human connection as the central cause; through his interaction with others, Grant defines himself as a better man, learning to accept his responsibilities and abandoning his sense of imprisonment and a hopeless future. This change is primarily due to contact with the positively portrayed characters in the novel-“as a result of his interactions with Jefferson, Vivian, Tante Lou, Reverend Ambrose, and Paul.” Poston also cites the effect of Grant on Jefferson; she presents the case that only through the basic friendship and connection between the two was Jefferson able to procure the strength to undergo his transformation from “hog” to dignified man. Poston states that Grant’s show of compassion and belief in Jefferson is enough to allow Jefferson to fulfill his role as a savior for the Black people.
    On a personal level, I strongly agree with this analysis. I feel that by having exposure to characters such as Paul, Tante Lou, Miss Emma, and Jefferson, Grant is forced to alter his cynical perspective on life. As stated by Poston, even though Grant is unwilling to teach Jefferson in jail, he feels bound to do so out of respect for others. It is these types of bonds which drive the entire story, whether it be between Grant and Aunt Emma or Vivian and her children. However, it is such contact that “rubs-off” on Grant; by experiencing the strength of Jefferson, in itself instilled by his friendship with Grant, Grant finds strength of his own, allowing him to change his feelings of hopeless abandon. Paul also plays an essential role as the exception to the racist white South; by interacting with just one white person who treats him with respect and equality, Grant is able to overcome his beliefs in a unified racist white community. I believe that this contrast in mentalities between Paul and his coworkers, as cited by Poston, is the key factor in the change of Grant’s views of the racist South.

    In response to “An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying, by Guest Author Jennie R Poston.” Aug 3, 2006

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Mr. Dileo, I'm sorry, before I tried to copy my abstract from a word perfect document where I typed it and it didn't copy correctly. There was an absense of spaces between the words and not everything was there. I will type it directly into a comment.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Sarah Margulis
    AP Literature – Period 1
    A Lesson Before Dying abstract
    September 26, 2009
    Mr. Di Leo

    Poston, Jennie R. “An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying.”

    This criticism of A Lesson Before Dying, proposes the idea that the novel is a story of humanity and the effect that people have on one another. The growth of Grant Wiggins, Jefferson, and their relationship between each other is a fine example of this effect. Poston says that Grant Wiggins begins faithless and cynical, but out of respect for the people that surround him, he is able to come out of the situation in which he feels imprisoned. Jefferson, on the other hand, has a defeatist attitude towards the prejudice that the white folk place upon him, but because of his relationship with Grant, Jefferson is able to become, “a hero for the black people.” Poston’s main point in this piece of literary criticism is that the change of the Grant and Jefferson happens in the novel, because of the connections between them. Jefferson is able to emerge heroic at the close of the novel because of his connection to Grant.

    I agree with what Poston says in her literary criticism of A Lesson Before Dying, because character connections are a constant force driving the novel. In the book, characters and their thoughts and beliefs and interactions are the main source that drives change in the characters. I agree with Poston that Grant starts out, “faithless and resentful towards the white folk’s prejudice attitudes,” but through his interactions with, “Vivian, Tante Lou, Reverend Ambrose, and Paul, he accepts his responsibilities,” and he is able to be there for Jefferson by showing Jefferson that he cares. That, “simple human connection,” between Jefferson and Grant is what gives Jefferson the strength to rise above the white folk. The prejudice from the white man is the antagonist to both Grant and Jefferson in the novel. Jefferson rises above it by dying a man. Grant rises above it by doing something with his life, helping Jefferson. The white man “depends on the dehumanization of the black population.” This is true all throughout the novel, however the connection between Grant and Jefferson allows each man to become more in tuned with who he is, zoned away from the prejudice. I agree with Poston that A Lesson Before Dying is “an intricate web of human connections,” and these connections are a driving force of change throughout the novel.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Kaila Proulx
    Mr. DiLeo
    Period 3 AP Literature
    Due: 9/29/09
    Abstract on A Lesson Before Dying

    Aug 3, 2006
    An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying, by Guest Author Jennie R Poston.

    Jennie R. Poston's analysis on the human connection in Ernest Gaines novel, A Lesson Before Dying, describes the effect of the black oppression of the South, the lack of opportunity for African Americans in the early 1900’s, and the overall racist attitude of the nation , on the main characters and the outcome of the story. In this piece, Poston explains Gaines’ method of using the growth of the main characters, Grant Wiggins and Jefferson, to the show the effect that people have on one another on a daily basis and in the long term. Poston believes the novel “centers on the relationship between Grant Wiggins, a local teacher, and Jefferson, a young black man falsely convicted of murder”, and slightly summarizes the interactions these two characters have with each other. She suggests that “Grant learns to accept his responsibilities as a result of his interactions with Jefferson, Vivian, Tante Lou, Reverend Ambrose, and Paul. These are the people that support him and encourage him to stay persistent with his mission. Poston suggests Grants frustration with his position in society and how he is seen as inferior to white people in his community. She concludes that “through his visits with Jefferson, Grant begins to lose some of his bitterness and cynicism” and that Grant rises above stereotypes and uses his inner strength to defy expectations.
    I agree with Jennie r. Poston’s analysis of the human element within A Lesson Before Dying, and believe she does a good job of summarizing the most important interactions in the story. I believe in the notion that through Grant’s conversations with Vivian his thoughts and frustrations are revealed and the way in which Gaines uses certain characters. For example, Gaines uses characters such as “Henri Pichot and Mr. Joseph Morgan to demonstrate the white mentality towards African Americans” in the period. When Poston describes Grant as a Christ like figure, she exaggerates his greatness. I believe her following description of Grant as a hero for black people in his community is much more accurate. Poston and I share the same opinion that Grant is able to get himself out of a rut through helping Jefferson and teaching him one final lesson before dying. Overall Poston shares the same conclusions I drew from the novel and analyzes the human connection the author describes in an accurate way.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Aaron Markel\
    AP Liturature period 3
    LBD Abstract
    9/28/09
    Mr. Dileo

    David J. Kelly examines Grant's inaction makes the reader uncomfortable. Grant has many good things that he does not apprichiate, Kelly goes on saying how Grant is a well educated man and he can actually do something with his life. Grant wants to leave the little town the lives in, but he cannot leave because he is tied to his town like a serf tied to the land. grant is tied to his town because of the widowed women like his aunt, Miss Emma, and Vivian. He wants to leave, but all Grant ever does is complain.
    I agree with this critism, Grant could have gone up north and made a decent living for himself, but he chose to stay and will be broken like many before him. grant could have even tried harder to do something besides complain, he was an outcast in his society, but he needed someone to come with him.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Jacob Lebsack
    Ap Lit
    Per. 5
    Mr. DiLeo
    9/28
    LBD Abstract

    Aug, 3, 2006
    An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying by, Guest Author Jennie R Poston

    Author Jennie R Poston's analysis of Ernest Gaine's A Lesson Before Dying is an in depth look into the novel's characters, relationships and messages. Poston carefully and acutely writes about each characters role and mindset within the story. She begins her work discussing the key relationship between Grant and the imprisoned young man, Jefferson. She describes Grant's lack of enthusiasm and confidence, calling him a "faithless, resentful man, reluctant to teach Jefferson to 'die like a man' ". Poston then goes on to state Grant's feelings towards the segregation and racism in the southern parts of the United States, saying the white characters in the novel "depend on the dehumanization of the black population in order to justify segregation and maintain their power". In this short analysis of A Lesson Before Dying, Jennie R Poston covers all the angles on basically all of the characters.
    I greatly believe that Poston's analysis of Gaines's novel is a quite accurate one. It truthfully depicts not only the facts that were given in the novel, but also the characters and their relationships within the story. While reading this piece, the reader is almost forced to agree with every statement due to the strong support it possesses from the book. I would've wished for the character analysis' to penetrate deeper than they did, but since it was simply a short piece, not everything can be expected. While reading this piece the first time i realized how important the relationships between the characters really were, the story was practically a spider web of people plastered over a situation. Overall, Poston achieved a job well done with her work An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's Novel, A lesson Before Dying.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Devin Kiblin
    AP Literature per.5
    Abstract
    9/28/09


    David J. Kelly explains how the protagonist Grant Wiggins of A Lesson Before Dying by Ernest J. Gaines could never just accept the good in his life. Kelly explains how Grant would shut himself out of the community in fear of being broken. Grant blames his aunt for trapping him and is just disappointed in his life. Kelly uses the example of Grant being distracted from his students but complaining they never learn; to show his hypocrisy. Kelly also notes that Grant thinks that Jefferson would be better off within the community then himself. By the end Kelly believes that Grant was a unique character, but also a strong example to learn from.
    Due to all the strong examples I agree with assessment of Grant. He is a character with few flaws, but also few strengths. Grant had a fear of being broken and Kelly saw this as the reason for out casting himself from society. Grant may be seen as an irritating character, but behind this is a real moral lesson that can be seen. Kelly likes the way Gaines uses Grant as a character that was “neither saintly nor profoundly flawed”. Kelly clearly knew what Gaines did because his criticism of Grant Wiggins was very strong.

    ReplyDelete
  12. An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying, by Guest Author Jennie R Poston.

    Jennie R. Poston explains the life of Jefferson as a black man living in the South in the 1940's. she also explains how brutal racism is and how it impacted Jefferson being falsely convicted of murder. Poston gives a brief analysis about the relationship between Grant Wiggins and Jefferson. She also explains Jeffersons' attempt to find strength from Grant. Grant is believed to find Jefferson a hero, as a black man rather. And this helps Jefferson to find the strength and ability to connect with Grant.
    I strongly agree with the response of the novel because Grant and Jeffersons relationship is what really shapes the novel. yes, the novel has to do with racism but its mainly pointed toward one thing, which is their friendship.this analysis gives you an accurate message of the novel.it gives you a good idea of the character of Jefferson. but i would've liked to get a stronger analysis of Jeffersons struggle to get comfortable with talking to Grant.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Jessica Rubino
    AP Literature- Period 1
    Abstracts
    September 28, 2009
    Mr. Di Leo
    David J. Kelly, in an essay for Novels for Students, Gale, 1999.

    This criticism by David J. Kelly focuses on Grant's personality and attitude towards the situation. Kelly describes how Grant's subtle passion and strong opinions make him a difficult and confusing character as he unwillingly visits Jefferson. Kelly argues that Grant was simply annoyed and unsympathetic as he struggles to reach Jefferson. David confirms that Grant can be nothing but frustrating. The only sense of credit Kelly gives Grant is making him a better person, by letting him see the world through his eyes. David J. Kelly provides an honest an unforgiving criticism of Grant Wiggins and his uneasy narration of A Lesson Before Dying.
    I agree with Kelly's criticism of Grant, mainly because I myself had difficulty not making assumptions about Grant. He can't find anything to be thankful for in his own life while he considers helping someone in need a burden. As the novel continues, as Jefferson begins to change, Grant opens up as well, showing more sympathy and a silent understanding with Jefferson. Although Kelly did not make many positive comments on him, I believe that by the end of the book Grant, although he has not become a better person, at least has become a little more appreciative of what he has. Honestly, learning about the conflict, I would have expected Grant to be a nervous, jittery character struggling to do whatever possible for Jefferson. Grant's simple personality provides us with a better understanding of the twisted ways of their society.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Indica Young
    Mr. DiLeo
    Period 5 AP Literature
    Due: 9/29/09
    Analysis of Human Connection in A Lesson Before Dying, written by Ernest Gaines by Guest Author Jennie R Poston.
    Jennie R. Poston analyzes A Lesson Before Dying and critiques it using human interaction, growth and change as the focus. Poston uses the interaction between the characters, especially Grant and Jefferson, to represent how individuals affect eachother. Although Grant was reluctant to visit Jefferson, he does and “through his visits with Jefferson, Grant begins to lose some of his bitterness and cynicism.”We see a similar affect on Jefferson after Grant’s visits supported by the fact that in the beginning Jefferson saw himself as a “hog” but by the time of his execution people can safely say that he died a man. Poston is pleased with the outcome of the relationship and appears to support the change in Grant and Jefferson. Through this criticism, Jennie Poston defends the ideals that man can change, and it can be greatly dependent on the people who surround you, the people that are active in your life.
    I greatly agree with Postons criticism of A Lesson Before Dying. I support her statements because throughout the book, no matter what the conflict, character growth through interaction was evident. At the beginning of the book, the demand that Jefferson die a man is made clear. I believe that this is only made possible when Grant interacts with Jefferson like he is a man, which occurs after Grant grows and changes as an individual. This change in Grant is driven by the interaction with “his Aunt, Tante Lou, and Jefferson's godmother, and Miss Emma” so inevitably the resolution of the book, Jefferson dying a man, is achieved through human synergy. Jennie R. Poston’s criticism offers up the importance of human growth and, and I am inclined to agree that it plays an enormous role in human nature.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Marissa Komanski
    AP Literature- Period 5
    Abstracts
    September 28, 2009
    Mr. Di Leo
    David J. Kelly, in an essay for Novels for Students, Gale, 1999.

    In Ernest Gaines’ A Lesson Before Dying, Grant Wiggins, a black school teacher in the 1940s, is put to the task of making sure that Jefferson, a man on trial for the assist in a store robbery, dies a man and not a hog in the electric chair. In David J. Kelly’s criticism of Grant Wiggins’ character, he speaks of Grant as being “difficult”. He doesn’t seem to know how to connect with Grant on a personal and empathetic level, because he isn’t like any other protagonist; “He is too well-educated to entirely hold our sympathies: we expect him to come up with a reason for putting up with being involved in this, but he keeps saying that he is only there to please others”. Kelly also spoke of becoming frustrated with Grant’s partial indifference to what was going on around him, and the fact that what he was made to look like was a man who only cared about the things that he was doing or had to do.
    In my opinion, I agree with David J. Kelly. When I read A Lesson Before Dying, I didn’t see Grant as the type of character that I could easily empathize with. He seemed to be irritated with everything that other people sort of guilt-tripped him into doing, like going to see Jefferson numerous times before he was sentenced to death. He wasn’t compassionate, and even to Vivian (the woman that he had feelings for) Grant didn’t seem to change emotionally or react to anything that someone else might have. While I didn’t loathe Grant’s presence in Gaines’ novel, I was a little disappointed throughout the story as Grant was being difficult with everything and everyone. It wasn’t until the end of the story that I really got to see how Grant felt, and it was sort of a lightening aspect to the story. Overall, however, Grant was a difficult character; I agree with David J. Kelly for thinking so.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Antiqua Jackson
    AP Literature - Period # 1
    A Lesson Before Dying Abstract
    September 28, 2009
    Mr. DiLeo

    An analysis of the human connection in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying, by Guest Author Jennie R Poston.

    Guest Author Jennie R Poston's analysis on A Lesson Before Dying, by Ernest Gaines, suggests that the novel is a story of humanity and the impact of the racial prejudice. Jennie uses Grant Wiggins and Jefferson growth to show an intricate web of human connections that Ernest Gaines has created, to subtly expose the effect people have on one another. She supports this idea by stating the dramatic changes that occur in the personalities of Grant and Jefferson as they grow as friends. Grant is described as a faithless, resentfully man, reluctant to teach Jefferson, and Jefferson is described as a sullen, withdrawn an believing himself to be no better than a hog. But as the novel progresses and as Grant and Jefferson get closer there descriptions change. Grant becomes known as a Christ figure; a hero for black people, and Jefferson is able to find strength and courage to rise above the white men's prejudice.

    Personally I agree with Jennie's criticism. I feel that she presented an idea and supported it with facts. I feel that A Lesson Before Dying is in fact a story of humanity and that the idea that Grant and Jefferson's connection exposed the effect people have on one another is overly true. I also agree with the way Jennie defended her statement by depicting Grants and Jefferson's personalities from the beginning of the novel to their courageous personalities at the end of the novel. I believe that including Grant and Jefferson's relationships with others created a wider range of the humanity and human connection in the novel. I agree with Jennie R Poston's criticism and it does in fact show that A Lesson Before Dying was a story of humanity and Ernest Gaines's intricate web of human connections exposed the effect people have on one another.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Alexandra Hughes
    AP Literature- Period 3
    Abstract
    September 28, 2009
    Mr. Di Leo

    In A lesson Before Dying, by Ernest Gaines, Grant Wiggins, a black school teacher is asked to make Jefferson a man by Jefferson's aunt. When Jefferson was accused of murder at a public store, he was sent to court and sentenced to death; but when the judge called him a pig, his aunt didn't want him to die a pig, she wanted him to die a man so she asked Grant to do so. In David J. Kelly's criticism of Grant, he claims that Grant is difficult and annoying and that he is uncomfortable with him.
    i disagree with Kelly about being uncomfortable with Grant. He's an interesting character who's just doing waht he is told. but i so agree with that Grant is difficult and can be annoying at some points. It's reasonablt for Grant o feel a certain way because s lot of pressure is being put on him, but he doesn't have to be that extreme about the way he acts towards others. All in all, Grant is a difficult character, to an extent.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Liam Cochrane
    AP Literature Period 5
    Mr. Dileo
    Abstracts

    An analysis of human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying, by Guest Author Jenny R. Poston

    Jenny Poston's analysis of A Lesson Before Dying relies heavily on a deeper interpretation of the human connections between the characters in the novel. Also focused on is the growth of the characters throughout the story. Poston tells that Grant, early on does not want to visit Jefferson, but he "begins to lose some of his bitterness and cynicism." Poston also emphasizes the views Grant has towards racism in the south. She tells how the white characters depend on their power and segregation to maintain their status in society, as well as describing the oppression faced by African-Americans in the 1900's south.
    I agree strongly with the views shared in this analysis of the novel, mainly because it strongly supports its theories with examples and true connections between characters. I also agree with her portrayal of Grant as a christ-like figure. I feel that it may be a bit of an exaggeration on her part, and it is more accurate when she calls him a "hero for the black people," because he is able to save a young man from a meaningless death and teach him to appreciate life. Overall, I believe that the connections drawn in the analysis are similar to those of my own.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Kyle Jemmott
    AP Literature-Period 3
    ALBD Abstract
    9/27/09
    Mr. Dileo

    The article discusses plot, symbolism and characters in a Lesson before dying. The author felt as though Grant deserved to be seen as an equal to the Caucasian people. The article discusses Jefferson as a Christ-like figure, a Messiah for the African American community of a lesson before dying. Characters such as Guidry and The Lawyers represented the way the majority of southern whites view blacks. The author said that Paul represented a tolerant Caucasian southerner.
    I disagree mostly with the article. To compare Jefferson to Christ is a comparison with little sustenance. Jefferson dying saved no one; if anything it did the opposite and increased the racial divide. Grant was not angry or bitter about his assignment, he just thought his task was impossible and underestimated himself. The article did however do a great job of representing the importance of Paul’s character, and what he symbolized. The author placed too much importance of the novel into race and not enough into pride and education.

    Response to “Human Connection” by Jennie R Poston

    ReplyDelete
  21. Aidan,

    An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying, by Guest Author Jennie R Poston.

    Jennie R. Poston discusses the life of Grant Wiggins, a man living in the rural South during the 1940s, and Jefferson, a black man convicted of murder. While Jefferson is on death row Grant is sent to visit him by his aunt, Tante Lou. Over the span of months Grant is forced initially to visit Jefferson, but after a while they form a close friendship. Grant is able to prepare and support Jefferson as the execution date becomes closer. Through Grant's support Jefferson is enabled to walk to the chair with more confidence and dignity than even the people watching the execution. Together they are able to defy the expectations of the racist white people in the town.

    I agree with this critique of A Lesson Before Dying because of the idea presented about the racism shown towards Grant and Jefferson. Although Jefferson probably would have been convicted no matter his color, because of the evidence compiled against him, he also experienced completely unneccessay acts of racism. A quick example of this is when people say that Jefferson is going to die like a hog. The statement I like most out of her critique is the closing sentence of "jefferson is able to find strength and courage to defy the white man's expectations and rise above the predjudice." I just thought that it was sadly ironic that in order to prove that he was stronger that the predjudice of white racists, Jefferson had to die.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Emma Walsh
    AP Literature
    ALBD Abstract
    9/28/09
    Mr. DiLeo

    The novel A Lesson Before Dying, set in Bayonne, a small town in Louisiana, illustrates the conflicting views on racial profiling in the late 1940’s. The novel is told in Grant’s point of view, as he builds his relationship with Jefferson, the boy Grant is trying to teach to be a man before he is executed. Jennie R. Poston claims that by the end of the novel “Grant begins to lose some of his bitterness and cynicism,” as his relationship with Jefferson, a character sometimes viewed as a “christ-like figure”, begins to fully develop. Even though Grant constantly considers himself more educated and equal to white men, he constantly vents to Vivan, his girlfriend, about running away, but if he actually ran away it would completely diminish the purpose of his teachings to Jefferson. A Lesson Before Dying, teaches the reader the effect that one person may have on another causing the character to become stronger.
    I strongly agree with Poston’s criticism of the novel. Jennie R Poston clearly explains that Grant exposes his true feelings when bonding with each individual character. Although Grant is hesitant to teach Jefferson, his views on humanity pushes him to attempt to reach out to Jefferson. Grant meets a guard named Paul, who is unlike most white people, because of his understanding towards racial diversity and equality. When meeting a person like Paul, it allows Grant to grow as a character and have a feeling of hope for the future. Poston’s analysis demonstrates the change throughout A Lesson Before Dying, by proving that one characters growth will dramatically effect another characters growth.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Fiona Hennig
    AP literature- period 5
    Lesson Before Dying Abstract
    9-27-09
    Mr. Di Leo

    An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying, by Guest Author Jennie R Poston.

    Jennie Poston writes that in A Lesson Before Dying the human relationships between the main characters in the novel lead to the growth and development of these characters, especially in the case of Grant Wiggins and Jefferson. Jefferson is sentenced to death after being accused of a murder to which he is innocent. Grant, being a well educated and respectable African American in the community, is pushed to spend time with Jefferson before he is executed. Grant’s knowledge is encouraged to be used to “teach Jefferson to ‘die like a man’" as stated by Poston. Grant visits Jefferson in jail often, and through these visits, Poston believes “Grant begins to lose some of his bitterness and cynicism” and “Jefferson is able to find strength and courage to defy the white man's expectations and rise above their prejudice”.
    I agree with Poston’s criticism on the effects of human interactions between Jefferson and Grant. I believe both character’s development rely strongly on the others presence. It is through Grants expression of warmth and compassion that Jefferson is able to die with dignity, and Jefferson’s ability to overcome the expectations of the white man with courage that Grant learns to not be so pessimistic about life. I think this is a great view on the book and is a good message to overall human interactions, which is that: knowledge and growth should be the main outcome of human relationships. I strongly agree with Proston’s idea that “an intricate web of human connections” is the leading source for character transformations within the novel.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Niamh Durfee
    AP Literature--Period 1
    ALBD Abstract
    September 28, 2009
    Mr. DiLeo


    Source: David J. Kelly, in an essay for Novels for Students, Gale, 1999.

    In his criticism of Ernest Gaines' novel A Lesson Before Dying, David Kelly dissects the narrator and protagonist, Grant Wiggins, and describes how his inaction throughout the story makes readers uneasy. Kelly makes clear that Gaines has crafted Wiggins in such a way as to illustrate the "complexity of life" and how there are always "the passive protagonists in life," marked by lack of strength of conviction though in control of their own destiny. However, the reader does not find himself sympathizing with Wiggins, since his indecision frequently turns to bitterness towards those he claims to care about in the novel, including Vivian, whom “he blames for holding him back," and his aunt Lou and others of the community, who have cut off all options other than to help Jefferson, he believes. In this sense he is a "difficult character," and Kelly states that he "kept waiting for [Wiggins] to choose what he wanted to be, to be what he chose to be," rather than leaving so many loose ends, both with himself and with his community. Though difficult, the reader is forced to consider the life of a black man in the South, a society in which he is rejected, and contemplate whether or not such an oppressive force would really limit "self-determination" as much as Wiggins claims it has limited him.
    Though I feel Kelly's analysis was overdone, trying too much to put feelings to words, I do strongly agree with the core of his criticism. With hindsight, I realize I too grew progressively more annoyed and more desperate for Wiggins to settle on something, though (as Kelly said) "I could not be sure that I was feeling it at all." Wiggins was indeed a "passive" yet practical narrator, whose lack of conviction and of certainty allowed for the reader's sympathies to turn to Jefferson. There was just enough indecision on the part of Wiggins for one to continually hope that some strength of character or some kind of resolve was just around the bend, only to have Wiggins let another opportunity to grasp "control of his destiny" slip by and disappoint me somewhat. Like Kelly, I feel that this was not unintentional, but was actually part of Gaines’ goal to represent reality, in all its complexity and shades of morality and meaning. Ultimately, the reader is forced out of a certain comfort zone to see the world for what it is through the eyes of an realistic though inactive protagonist.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Joseph Gardella
    AP Lit
    ALBD Abstract
    9/28/09
    Mr. Dileo

    David J. Kelly's essay summarizes several major points of the novel specifically revolving around Grant and at times Jefferson, Tante Lou, and Miss Emma.
    It provides a unique perspective as to the characterization of the protagonist and those around him. For instance, as stated you cannot over simplify each character, and their actions, as either completely good or evil, instead one is left coming up with their own assumption. While Jefferson did not plan the murder/robbery, he did take money out of the cash register, a piece of information that helps jail himself. The writer also references Grant's more "annoying" qualities: his constant whining but inaction to do anything, his feeling trapped though one can argue he causes it, and his lack of dedication to his work yet complaining the students aren't learning anything. He states that the novel might be more enjoyable if Grant had done something more heroic, though the meaning would be lost.

    I completely agree with the author of this essay. Not only does Grant not do anything to change his situation, he blames others for the fact that he is in it in the first place, which in my opinion is somewhat disgusting. He is not someone who I can easily sympathize with yet I tolerate him enough to look at his point of view, obviously the intention of the Gaines, and something Kelly pointed out. Also while I don't agree with some of his actions or his personality, one can understand why he is like how he is. In a way Kelly takes both sides of the story, accusing Grant of inaction but also describing just why he does it. This I agree with above all else, though it might seem like I've contradicted myself from the beginning of this, I've merely pointed out two things which I agree with to varying levels. Kelly's opinion is one I can respect.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Jack Alfieri
    Per 4 AP lit
    Mr. Dileo
    Abstract
    9/28/09

    David J. Kelly explains how Grant Wiggins is not an easy character to like. He explains how he has neither to many flaws or strengths and therefore it is hard to get a strong read for him. Kelly also explains how he does not particularly Grant because he is unwilling to accept the good in his life and because he shuts himself out of the community in fear of being broken. Grant pushes away the few people that love him and blames his aunt for trapping him and his girlfriend for holding him back. In the end of the article, Kelly concludes with saying that he is glad he got to see life through Grants eyes but overall does not like Grant as a character.
    I do agree with Kelly's analysis of Grant and how he is a hard character to like and agree with. I think it is hard to like Grant for the reasons stated by Kelly. Grant does not have many flaws or strengths and cannot decide what he wants to do or be and becase of this it is hard for me as a reader to make a strong cocclusion about Grant and his character.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Chris Cieslik
    AP literature- period 5
    Lesson Before Dying Abstract
    9-28-09
    Mr. DiLeo

    Jennie R. Poston shows how characters interact and how they all tend to effect in each other in Ernest Gaines, A Lesson Before Dying. At first Grant is selfish and stubborn when it comes to visiting Jefferson, but he does it for his Tante Lou. Through his visits Grant grows as a person and the reader begins to see a deeper meaning in the text. Which is how bad blacks were treated in the south in the 1940's. Jefferson is Grants way of proving to everyone that black people arent a joke, in fact they are just as good as the whites. Grant begins to gain strength as a character and starts to show a sense of pride in making Jefferson a man.
    I would have to agree with what was written by Ms Poston. Anyone can change anybody that they want to. In Grants eyes uneducated blacks were worthless and he didnt think there was a thing he could do to change that. His Tante Lou wanted Grant to change Jefferson and that he did. Jefferson died a man and it was with Grants help. Showing that the characters in this book did learn from one another. Grant learned that not everything is hopeless with blacks in the south and Jefferson learned that his life wasnt worthless.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Dylan Burns
    AP Literature Period 1
    A Lesson Before Dying Abstract
    9-28-09
    Mr. Dileo


    In response to: “An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying”, by Guest Author Jennie R Poston


    This work proposes that humans cannot live their lives fully, without the compassion and aid of friends, loved ones, and even strangers. It depicts how empty and sparse the lives of the main characters, Jefferson and Grant, were before they connected with each other. Although it was not instant, Jefferson and Grant began to help each other understand themselves on a higher and more passionate degree, through the simple form of human connection. Jefferson realized that he was neither a hog, nor a criminal, like the government emphasized he was, and he could finally say goodbye to the world with some shred of dignity, no matter how minuscule. Grant began to understand that although he despised his teaching job, he was teaching the children of his friends and families to stand up for themselves through knowledge. He was gradually aiding the oppressive quality that he despised in white men, to deteriorate and become nullified. Miss Poston emphasizes that people become who they are, and resolve issues in themselves through the contact and connection of others. Without this connection, life as we know it would consist of emptiness and people would wallow in their own problems.

    I agree with Miss Poston’s ideals to a point. I believe that humans are elevated to a higher degree through the connection with other humans, and with the help of those around them. I think that humans are not perfect, and can always utilize a guiding hand to help them, or to illustrate to them how to help themselves. This is especially true when the individual cannot visualize any solution for themself, or if they just don’t care enough to try. While I agree thus far with Miss Poston’s ideas, my ideas begin to differentiate. I believe that humans are not wholly dependant on others for their own survival. Humans are the dominant species in this world, and it is my belief that they can survive individually on their own. However, I also believe that a life of seclusion without the aid of others, would lead to a lesser life, because human connection enhances life.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Stephanie Glick
    AP Literature Period-1
    A Lesson Before Dying Abstract
    9-28-09
    Mr. DiLeo

    An analysis of human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying, by Guest Author Jenny R. Poston.

    Jennie R. Poston's analysis of Earnest Gaine's A Lesson Before Dying is written about the human connections seen through the novel. Poston explains how the characters Grant Wiggins and Jefferson are used to show the racism and injustice in the rural south during the 1940's. Though hesitant to become involved in helping Jefferson, Grant is eventually able to make Jefferson believe that he, Jefferson, is not a hog. Grant does this by consistently visiting Jefferson, and he shows Jefferson that he cares about him. Grant is also treated as though he is inferior to white men, yet through meeting Jefferson in jail, he learns that there are people who treat African Americans with respect(Paul). Poston explains that by the end of the novel Jefferson "[dies] with the dignity of a man," showing white men that he was a better person than what they thought he was. Jefferson became a "hero for the black people."

    I strongly agree with Jennie R. Postons statements about A Lesson Before Dying. Grant's visits to the prison, not only helped Jefferson see himself as a man, but it took away some of Grant's bitterness, and gave him somewhat of a positive outlook. In the novel, it is disgusting to see how Grant, an educated man, is treated so poorly by white men. The "dehumanization" of blacks is necessary for them because it is they're only justification for treating those with a different ethnicity poorly. Even though Grant was hesitant to help Jefferson in the first place, by doing so he not only helped Jefferson , but also himself, and the whole African American community. Jefferson represented strength and dignity in a time of weakness and sadness.

    ReplyDelete
  30. is it just my computer or does the time appear as three hours slow?

    ReplyDelete
  31. Hey, Mr. DiLeo. I finally got the blog to work, so here's my abstract:

    Jen Shelton
    AP Literature - Period 1
    ALBD Abstract
    September 28, 2009
    Mr. DiLeo


    Jenny R. Poston has taken an in-depth look at "A Lesson Before Dying" by Ernest Gaines, as is evident in her summarization of the novel. Poston comments thoughtfully on the relationships between characters in the novel, specifically the one that grows between Grant Wiggins and Jefferson. The author also takes extreme care to point out Grant's hostility toward white men, mainly due to their inhumane treatment of him and other African Americans in his hometown and around the South. Poston accurately describes the helplessness and desolation present in Grant's thoughts about his "useless" teaching, and his being forced into visiting Jefferson in the jail, and helping him to "die like a man." The author shows the outlets that allow you insight into Grant's thoughts, and concludes her essay by describing the changes that his relationship with Jefferson have made on Grant, as well as Ernest Gaines's presentation of Jefferson in the novel.

    I agree whole-heartedly with Ms. Poston. Her facts are solid and the background knowledge of the story presented is correct. The descriptions in her essay of the mistreatment of African Americans present the cruelty and inhumane practices of the white men in the novel, and her characterization of Grant is terrific. He is indeed a somewhat bitter, cynical man in the beginning of the novel, but his relationship with Jefferson brings him new perspective, changing certain traits of his personality. I also agree with Poston’s take on Jefferson’s role in the novel, and the way Grant helps him to achieve his full potential as a hero for African Americans before his death.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Christopher Prentiss
    AP Literature Period: 5
    LBD Abstract
    9/28/09
    Mr. DiLeo

    Jennie R Poston. “An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying” April 3, 2006

    Scholar Jennie Poston gives an in-depth look at the characters and themes behind A Lesson Before Dying by Ernst J. Gaines, and talks about how Gaines uses “an intricate web of human connections, using the character growth of Grant Wiggins and Jefferson to subtly expose the effect people have on one another”. She mentions how Grant starts out the novel skeptical that he can help Jefferson to “die like a man” but as the novel moves on Grant becomes more and more open to helping Jefferson out due to his interactions with other characters. She talks about how Gaines uses characters like Sheriff Guidry and Henri Pichot to symbolize the white ideals towards African Americans in the specific time and place in which this novel occurs; the only exception to this is Paul, who is tolerant and compassionate to African Americans. She notes Grant’s frustration in his current situation and you can see this in his conversations with his girlfriend, Vivian. In the end, she says that Jefferson finally dies like a man and becomes a Christ like figure for the black people and Grant is finally able to reach him by “showing him that he cares for and believes in him”.

    I agree with the assessment that Jennie Poston made on Ernest Gaines’s A Lesson Before Dying, she had many strong points and backed them up with great examples from the book. In her assessment she talks about the prejudice in racism in the Bayonne area during that time period and she accurately talks about the white mentality towards African Americans which is personified by Henri Pichot and Sheriff Guidry. I also like how she talked about the progression of Grant as a person throughout the novel, he starts off very bitter and somewhat harsh towards the idea of helping Jefferson but as he progresses he becomes more and more confident in Jefferson. I also agree with her talking about Jefferson being a “Christ like” figure, I think that is a great analogy, because truly that is what Jefferson is. Overall she makes a great connection between the characters and the main themes of the story.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Hi Mr. DiLeo.

    Sam Scheiten
    Ap Literature-Per. 5
    LBD Abstract
    September 28,2009
    Mr. DiLeo

    Jennie R. Poston gives great insight into A Lesson Before Dying. The protagonist Grant Wiggins is a schoolteacher in the south in the 1940s'. A man named Jefferson is comdemned to death for a crime he did not commit. During his trial he is referred to as a hog in having no human qualities, he also sees himself as a hog. Grant Wiggins is then assigned to help Jefferson become a man before his execution. Grant then visits Jefferson in prison and shows him how to die like a man, by receiving an education.
    A agree fully with Poston; she gives a relevant analysis to this work of literary merit. She shows that the characters develop a relationship with each other, but at first, they didn't want to bother with each other. At the end of the story Jefferson became a man and was executed.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Lauren Samar
    AP Lit and Comp- Period 5
    Abstracts
    9/28/09
    Mr. Di Leo

    Jennie R. Poston uses the “intricate web of human connections” that Ernest Gaines created in his novel, A Lesson Before Dying, to evaluate the cause of other characters on Grant. Some characters such as Sheriff Guidry, Henri Pichot, and Mr. Joseph Morgan, empathizes the radical difference in a way that belittles and dehumanized the African Americans. Grant resents those empathizes, feels equal to those men because of his education, and is embittered by the lack of ability to do any thing about it. The relationship between Grant and other characters cause the eventual change in him because through other characters, Grant learns to accept responsibility as well as becoming less bitter. Grant tried to avoid going to see Jefferson but did so anyways “out of respect for his Aunt, Tante Lou, and Jefferson’s godmother, Miss Emma”. His relationship Jefferson helped Jefferson find strength and courage to rise above the white man’s expectations.

    I agree with Poston’s analysis of human connections because I believe that people can grow as a person based on experience in relationships and interacting. Because Grant grew up in a cruel and unfair time for African Americans, he became resentful and bitter of whites. In his relationship with Vivian, he learned responsibility. Grant and Jefferson’s relationship helped each other grow as a person because Grant showed Jefferson “that he cares for and believes in him”. In return, Grant learned the value of believing in oneself. One of the lessons from this novel, which is empathized in this analysis, is that human connections can affect people in negative as well as positive ways but they always teach something.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Joseph Patnella
    AP Literature per 3
    Abstract
    9/28/09

    In Jennie R Poston’s analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying, explains how life for Jefferson as an African American in the south during the 1940’s. It describes how racist the white people of the south are to African Americans and how Jefferson is wrongly being charged with murder. Poston gives a short analysis about the relationship between Grant and Jefferson. Poston also explains Jefferson’s attempt to find strength from Grant. After a while Grant is believed to find Jefferson a hero, not just as an African American but as person as well. This helps Jefferson to find the power and confidence to connect with Grant.
    I agree with the response of the novel because Grant and Jefferson’s relationship is what the novel is shaped around. Although the novel has a point of view from a racist’s point of view but its mainly pointed toward one thing, which is the friendship between Grant and Jefferson. The analysis gives you an accurate message of the novel. It gives you a good idea of the character of Jefferson. I believe it would have been more interesting to get a deeper understanding of Jefferson’s difficulty to get comfortable with talking to Grant from this analysis.

    ReplyDelete
  36. fairies415=sarah!!!! i think im going to type this up and hand it in to you tomorrow

    ReplyDelete
  37. Mr. Di Leo, I had to post this as 2 different posts because it's too long...that should tell me something right? Haha.

    Megan Krug
    AP Literature, Period 5
    9/28/09
    Abstract
    Mr. Di Leo

    An analysis of the human connections in Ernest Gaines's novel A Lesson Before Dying, by Guest Author Jennie R. Poston.

    Jennie R. Poston’s analysis of A Lesson Before Dying focuses on “humanity and the impact of racial prejudice” between the white majority and the undermined black community of Bayonne, Louisiana during the 1940’s. She states that Gaines “weaves an intricate web of human connections, using the character growth of Grant Wiggins and Jefferson to subtly expose the effect people have on one another.” Grant, a school teacher made bitter by the oppression and injustice towards black society, unwillingly helps the illiterate yet sincere Jefferson who, in having been falsely convicted of murder, yearns to “die like a man” rather than “a hog”. Due to Grant’s faithless and resentful constitution, he sees “Jefferson's incarceration as further proof that his teaching has no impact on [his] students” and is “unwilling to put himself at the mercy of Sheriff Guidry” or any of the white men for that matter. Grant, an educated man, feels he should be equal to the white men rather than be treated as their inferior, adding to his cynical outlook on life. Poston sums Grant’s bleak attitude up to a feeling of being “trapped in his present situation,” but it is “out of respect for his Aunt, Tante Lou, and Jefferson's godmother, Miss Emma, [that] he agrees to talk to [Jefferson].” As the novel progresses, however, Poston points out that Grant begins to “accept his responsibilities as a result of his interactions with Jefferson, Vivian, Tante Lou, Reverend Ambrose, and Paul.” Grant and Jefferson’s interactions evolve from a frustrating and stubborn miscommunication to a powerful understanding between the two men. As stated by Poston, “Grant begins to lose some of his bitterness and cynicism” as “he comes to believe that if Jefferson succeeds in dying with the dignity of a man he will achieve a level of salvation,” therefore representing the black population is a positive light. Grant emulates Jefferson’s bravery a presents him as a “Christ figure” and finally reaches Jefferson by “showing him that he cares for and believes in him.” Poston discovers that “it is by [this] simple human connection that Jefferson is able to find strength and courage to defy the white man's expectations and rise above their prejudice.”

    ReplyDelete
  38. When Poston talks about Grant in the beginning of her analysis, she describes him as a resentful and persecuted black man in an all-white society. In my opinion, Grant was not only bitter but felt trapped within his community and no matter what he did, would always be treated as an inferior to the white race. Because of this he decided to give up fighting for equal representation and believed, in my opinion, that everyone else should do the same. That is why he did not feel as though he had to help Jefferson. In doing so he thought he would just be providing evidence to the point that black people would always be viewed beneath white. I think that, unconsciously, this bothered Grant because he finally gave into the aunts’ persuasions to go and help Jefferson, despite the fact that he believed it wouldn’t work. He stubbornly held to this assumption when Jefferson refused his teaching. This caused Grant to sink deeper into his bitterness because he knew that he was right in believing the African American status in society could not be changed, despite the fact he wanted it to. Through Jefferson, however, he began to see that there was so much more to the black community than he had initially given credit to. He began to admit that Jefferson could really make a statement strong enough to cause impact on the white community. Although this revelation didn’t completely cure Grant of his bitter outer shell, I believe that it was the catalyst for many similar revelations to come. He was moved by Jefferson’s bravery and was ashamed that such a good man had to die. I also agree with Jefferson being referred to as a Christ figure because, for me, he represented the salvation of the black people as a whole. Just like Christ, Jefferson, although unwilling at first, gave up his life for the benefit of the black community. Not exactly the savior of the entire African American population due to the fact that his unjust treatment was one of many throughout the world, Jefferson still managed to illuminate the injustice being carried out not only to him but to his people. In the end Grant was convinced that there was hope for the African American people, demonstrating how, through basic human connection, a subtle yet significant event can have such a big effect on society.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Anthony Solomon
    AP English
    Abstract
    9/28/09
    Period 3

    David Jelly describes how Grant Wiggins of Ernest J. Gaines work, "A Lesson Before Dying", couldn't feel good about life. David describes how Grant blames his aunt for trapping him, and how he isn't content with his life how it is. Grant also keeps himself out of the community. Hypocrisy is shown when Grant is distracted from his students, but then complaining how they fail to learn. Grant also believe that Jefferson would would be better off within the community then himself.

    I do agree with this analysis of Grant. Grant is a character with weaknesses and strengths. Grant was afraid of being broken, which provided a reason for shunning him from the community. Grant can be viewed as annoying, depressed character, but there is a lesson behind that. I like the way how Gaines used Grant as a character that wasn't the greatest nor the worst, just average. It goes to show how the average person, can be the greatest teacher.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Jessina Cole
    Ap Literature Period 5
    9/29/09
    Abstract
    Mr.DiLeo
    Analysis of Human Connections
    A Lesson Before Dying, by Guest Author Jennie R. Poston.

    Jennie Poston analyzes Grant Wiggins, and Jeffersons life in A Lesson Before Dying by Ernest Gaines. Grant Wiggins, a black school teacher in Bayonne Louisiana in the 1940's, was assigned the task to "turn Jefferson into a man" before his sentenced death. Jefferson was wrongly accused of multiple murders when in all actuality he was the only witness, but unfortunately the only one left alive at the crime scene. One of the main reasons he was persecuted is because Bayonne was a dominantly white town and people were very prejudice. Jefferson usually found himself feeling inferior and helpless toward the nearly all white society. Grant helped Jefferson realize that if he was going to die, he would have to die a proud black man, with dignity and respect, even though Grant at first declined the offer. He taught Jefferson to trust in god although he himself had lost all hope and trust that he had in god. I agree with her analysis of all of the main characters in the book because she depicts them based on the ways they matured. Poston tells how Grant developed from being a bitter, school teacher, with barely any hope left, to someone who somewhat believed in god, had hope and had develpoed a relationship with Jefferson.

    ReplyDelete

  • Human Connection
  • Grant's Inaction
  •